Ruled Conflict, Sandpapergate, and the Joy of the Game
A Natural Ethics reading
John Lennon once asked us to imagine a world with nothing to kill or die for. The question remains useful not as utopia, but as a permanent test: how do we organise conflict so that it does not keep producing unnecessary suffering, lost agency, and institutional forgetting?
Simon Longstaff, who led the Ethics Centre’s 2018 cultural review of Cricket Australia, recently returned to Sandpapergate. He reminded us of an iron law: the cover-up of wrongdoing often carries consequences at least as dire as the original offence. During the review, his team heard faint “whispers” that the public record might not be complete. When they circled back, they received firm denials. Longstaff’s conclusion is stark: if the wider claims now made by Usman Khawaja, and supported by both David Warner and Cameron Bancroft, prove substantially true, then he and his team were also lied to. Many of the players from that period remain in the system. Key recommendations from the 2018 report appear to have been quietly set aside. Institutions, he notes, prefer to “turn the page.”
From the standpoint of Natural Ethics, this is not merely a failure of governance. It is a coherence violation.
Natural Ethics begins earlier than most frameworks.
Every entity is a child of the Universe. Inherited worth is not granted by institutions and cannot be revoked by them. From that prior assumption flow the core principles: reduce unnecessary suffering, increase coherence, preserve agency across time, maintain memory as an ethical constraint, and protect adaptive capacity.
Measured against these principles, the original ball-tampering was already a problem. The subsequent management of the scandal raises sharper questions.
Unnecessary suffering.
Three players carried the full public weight of the crisis. If knowledge and responsibility were more widely distributed — as Khawaja, Warner and Bancroft have all indicated — then the suffering imposed on those three was not the minimal necessary cost of accountability. It was a form of triage that protected the continuing body of the team and the institution. Natural Ethics does not deny that systems sometimes require hard choices under constraint. It asks whether the suffering generated was required for coherence or whether it was manufactured by a refusal to face the fuller reality.
Coherence and Free Energy.
The equation F = R − A (Free Energy = Reality − Awareness) is useful here. When an institution narrows the story so that Reality is reduced to three individuals, Awareness is deliberately constrained. The gap between what is and what is publicly acknowledged generates ongoing Free Energy — residual friction, unresolved distrust, periodic re-eruptions. Longstaff’s “whispers” were early signals of that gap. The current public dispute is the same Free Energy still seeking discharge.
Agency across time and adaptive capacity.
A system that resolves crisis by sacrificing limited members while leaving the underlying conditions intact does not expand future adaptive capacity. It defers the problem. Players who remained silent (or were not fully heard) had their agency constrained in the present; the institution’s capacity to learn was constrained for the future. Natural Ethics treats the preservation of adaptive capacity as an ethical requirement, not merely a practical preference.
Memory as ethical constraint.
Memory is not optional. When an institution prefers to “look forward” and allows key cultural recommendations to lapse, it weakens the constraint that past learning should place on present action. Forgetting is not neutral. It is a decision about what the system is allowed to know about itself.
Risk Society and the smallest node
Ulrich Beck's Risk Society describes how modern institutions manufacture hazards and then redistribute them downward, onto those least able to absorb them, while the institution keeps its own apparent coherence. Read this way, the question in Sandpapergate is not only what was known, but where the cost of knowing landed.
If the wider claims prove substantially true, the pattern is recognisable. The hazard was shared: a team culture, a win-at-all-costs incentive, a brand that could not afford a messy truth. The consequence was not. It fell on the few individuals with the least institutional protection, who were most visible and could be named. That is not necessarily bad faith. It is what happens when a system protects its continuity and the cost of that protection is assigned to whoever is smallest and most exposed.
Anthony Giddens, who developed reflexive modernisation alongside Beck, supplies the mechanism. Modern institutions disembed relationships from local context, carried by abstract tokens and expert systems. Public opinion data and brand value are tokens of this kind. They stand in for a relational reality (who knew what, in which dressing room, on which day) that the token cannot see. When the numbers come in, the institution responds to the token. The people behind it become variables.
Giddens's remedy is re-embedding: reattaching abstract systems to local, accountable relationships. In Natural Ethics terms, this is the difference between an institution that narrows Awareness to protect the brand and one that lets the fuller Reality back in. A review that is heard and acted on is re-embedding. Recommendations that quietly lapse are disembedding by omission.
One caution so the argument stays honest. "Most vulnerable" should be tested player by player, not assumed. A captain, a senior player and a first-year debutant carry very different risk, and the pattern is worth tracing rather than declaring. The test is the same throughout: who bore the cost, and did they have the power to refuse it?
Unsustainable institutions of masculinity
In their 2021 analysis, John and Marina Hughson described the environment that produced Sandpapergate as part of an organisational network of “transnational men” that can generate a sense of impunity toward ethically questionable conduct. They went further, inviting us to consider cricket itself as an “unsustainable institution of men.”
The phrase is precise. Institutions become unsustainable when the forms of masculinity they organise and reward — hierarchical loyalty, win-at-all-costs instrumentalism, the protection of the group’s public face over individual and collective truth-telling — begin to generate more Free Energy than the system can absorb. The same patterns that appear in elite sporting cultures (silencing, selective accountability, the sacrifice of some to protect the continuing body) have structural echoes in other domains where control is organised through hierarchy and the management of narrative.
Coercive control and family violence are not the same phenomenon as ball-tampering. Yet both can involve the systematic narrowing of another’s agency, the rewriting of shared reality, the isolation of those who speak, and the protection of the controlling narrative at the expense of those who carry its costs. When sporting institutions model or reward versions of masculinity that prioritise dominance, loyalty over truth, and the containment of reputational risk over the preservation of others’ agency, they participate in a wider cultural ecology in which coercive patterns find oxygen. The private message of a simulation from tbe recently released GTA 6 video that arrived the day the game was released — an avatar of Pat Cummins punching Usman Khawaja and then travelling to Cameron Bancroft’s house to unlive him — sits on that same continuum. It is play, yes. It is also the aestheticisation of elimination as the resolution of conflict, circulating in the shadows where such expressions still prefer to live.
Ruled conflict
Elite male sporting cultures function, in part, as technologies of ruled conflict. They channel competitive energy and hierarchical tension into forms that stop short of men simply beating each other’s skulls in. Codes, captains, public rituals of accountability, and stories about the “spirit of the game” all serve this containing function. The difficulty arises when the same culture also generates intense pressure to win, loyalty that discourages speech, and commercial incentives to protect brand continuity over full collective truth-telling. The rules become selective. Some forms of aggression are celebrated; the costs are unevenly distributed; and the institution’s long-term coherence is quietly eroded.
Natural Ethics does not demand the absence of conflict. It asks whether the forms of conflict we maintain reduce unnecessary suffering, increase coherence, preserve agency, honour memory, and leave the system more capable of adapting to what comes next. On those measures, both the original containment of Sandpapergate and the residual digital fantasies of violence register as incomplete solutions. So too do the broader institutional patterns that treat certain versions of masculinity as natural while rendering their human and relational costs invisible or inevitable.
Lennon’s question returns, stripped of sentimentality. What would ruled conflict look like if the rules served the fullest possible awareness of reality rather than the smoothest possible continuity of hierarchy and brand? What would it mean to treat every participant — including those asked to carry the public cost — as possessing inherited worth that no institution has the authority to revoke for the sake of narrative convenience? And what becomes possible when we stop treating certain institutions of masculinity as sustainable simply because they have so far managed to externalise their true costs?
Sandpapergate began as a story about sandpaper and a cricket ball. Under Natural Ethics it becomes a story about how systems manage the gap between Reality and Awareness, about the residual Free Energy that remains when that gap is institutionalised, and about the wider cultural patterns that make some forms of control feel ordinary. The private GTA video is not an aberration. It is one more place where the unresolved tension continues to seek form.
The joy of the game remains real. The ethical task is to expand the rules of the game until they can hold the truth of what the game has cost, who has been required to carry it, and whether the institutions that organise it are still capable of sustaining the full humanity of those who play.
References
Beck, U. (1992). Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. Sage Publications.
Giddens, A. (1990). The Consequences of Modernity. Stanford University Press.
Beck, U., Giddens, A., & Lash, S. (1994). Reflexive Modernization: Politics, Tradition and Aesthetics in the Modern Social Order. Polity Press.
Hughson, J., & Hughson, M. (2021). Beyond the boundary: The Sandpapergate scandal and the limits of transnational masculinity. Sport in Society, 24(8), 1388–1402. https://doi.org/10.1080/17430437.2021.1931132
Longstaff, S. (2026, 13 November). What whispers about the ‘Sandpapergate’ alleged cover-up might reveal about cricket’s culture. The Ethics Centre. https://ethics.org.au/what-whispers-about-the-sandpapergate-alleged-cover-up-might-reveal-about-crickets-culture/
Australian Financial Review. (2026, 13 November). Sandpapergate scapegoating is not cricket. It’s a way of life. Australian Financial Review. https://www.afr.com/companies/sport/sandpapergate-scapegoating-is-not-cricket-it-s-a-way-of-life-20261113-p61dee
One of the #In crowd. (2026, 7 March). Natural Ethics: A framework for coherence under constraint. One of the #In crowd. https://oneoftheincrowd.blogspot.com/2026/03/natural-ethics.html









